
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/co ... 02712.html
Moonduck wrote:Bravery and humility, this is what a hero is made of.
You are exactly diminishing the actions of Sgt. Guinta. Your rage against our President now leads you to start comparing Medal of Honor Citations? Will you now compare all other MOH citations to the one you listed? I guess you are saying some MOH awards are more equal than others? That's exactly the kind of controversy we don't need, that btw can apply to every decoration ever awarded. Way to go, thanks for damning this young soldier with faint praise simply because you hate the President? Thanks for hinting that this recipient's actions were not worthy of the MOH. I wonder if you even know how MOH's are approved, or if you know that MOH awards are rarely free from a lot of stuff that have nothing to do with the particular action, and that standards varied from theater to theater, service to service, and war to war. The one conclusion any study of the history of awards and decorations shows is that comparing citations is IMPOSSIBLE and MEANINGLESS!GS78 wrote:. On 28 June 2005, operating in an extremely rugged enemy-controlled area, Lieutenant Murphy?s team was discovered by anti-coalition militia sympathizers, who revealed their position to Taliban fighters. As a result, between 30 and 40 enemy fighters besieged his four-member team. Demonstrating exceptional resolve, Lieutenant Murphy valiantly led his men in engaging the large enemy force. The ensuing fierce firefight resulted in numerous enemy casualties, as well as the wounding of all four members of the team. Ignoring his own wounds and demonstrating exceptional composure, Lieutenant Murphy continued to lead and encourage his men. When the primary communicator fell mortally wounded, Lieutenant Murphy repeatedly attempted to call for assistance for his beleaguered teammates. Realizing the impossibility of communicating in the extreme terrain, and in the face of almost certain death, he fought his way into open terrain to gain a better position to transmit a call. This deliberate, heroic act deprived him of cover, exposing him to direct enemy fire. Finally achieving contact with his Headquarters, Lieutenant Murphy maintained his exposed position while he provided his location and requested immediate support for his team. In his final act of bravery, he continued to engage the enemy until he was mortally wounded, gallantly giving his life for his country and for the cause of freedom. By his selfless leadership, courageous actions, and extraordinary devotion to duty, Lieutenant Murphy reflected great credit upon himself and upheld the highest traditions of the United States Naval Service.
http://www.cmohs.org/recipient-detail/2 ... hael-p.php
I am in no way diminishing the medal of honor Staff Sgt.Guinta is going to recieve , I am merely pointing out that although his story is exceptional in courage , its really not extraordinary. Read some of the other MOH winners stories.....http://www.cmohs.org/featured-recipients.php
Y
after reading some of these articles you soon realize that its Obama, who needs this event to happen.
Yes, this has been a long standing concern even when Bush was in office. Why wasn't he handing out any MoHs to living soldiers? I suspect politics has more to do with deciding who gets one rather than who deserves one. Staff Sgt. Guinta deserves it, but it is hard to understand how no other living soldier in the past 9 years hasn't earned one too.GS78 wrote:. On 28 June 2005, operating in an extremely rugged enemy-controlled area, Lieutenant Murphy?s team was discovered by anti-coalition militia sympathizers, who revealed their position to Taliban fighters. As a result, between 30 and 40 enemy fighters besieged his four-member team. Demonstrating exceptional resolve, Lieutenant Murphy valiantly led his men in engaging the large enemy force. The ensuing fierce firefight resulted in numerous enemy casualties, as well as the wounding of all four members of the team. Ignoring his own wounds and demonstrating exceptional composure, Lieutenant Murphy continued to lead and encourage his men. When the primary communicator fell mortally wounded, Lieutenant Murphy repeatedly attempted to call for assistance for his beleaguered teammates. Realizing the impossibility of communicating in the extreme terrain, and in the face of almost certain death, he fought his way into open terrain to gain a better position to transmit a call. This deliberate, heroic act deprived him of cover, exposing him to direct enemy fire. Finally achieving contact with his Headquarters, Lieutenant Murphy maintained his exposed position while he provided his location and requested immediate support for his team. In his final act of bravery, he continued to engage the enemy until he was mortally wounded, gallantly giving his life for his country and for the cause of freedom. By his selfless leadership, courageous actions, and extraordinary devotion to duty, Lieutenant Murphy reflected great credit upon himself and upheld the highest traditions of the United States Naval Service.
http://www.cmohs.org/recipient-detail/2 ... hael-p.php
I am in no way diminishing the medal of honor Staff Sgt.Guinta is going to recieve , I am merely pointing out that although his story is exceptional in courage , its really not extraordinary. Read some of the other MOH winners stories.....http://www.cmohs.org/featured-recipients.php
after reading some of these articles you soon realize that its Obama, who needs this event to happen.
SSG Guinta, I salute you and all other servicemen and women.OakRidgeStars wrote:U.S. Army to award living soldier Medal of Honor for first time since Vietnam war. It's about time.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/co ... 02712.html