Page 1 of 2

ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Fri, 07 Jan 2011 10:39:42
by TheGodfather
...for non-citizens. :doh:

http://www.foxnews.com/us/2011/01/06/ne ... latestnews
In what might appear to be a shotgun wedding of opposites, the ACLU has filed a lawsuit on behalf of a non-U.S. citizen alleging that South Dakota's concealed weapons law violates his constitutional right to bear arms.



Re: ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Fri, 07 Jan 2011 10:59:39
by ShortMan
The American Civil Liberties Union has spent most of its time recently protecting illegal aliens. Which is funny.
Until you realize they are part of the reason illegals are made to feel welcome and able to stay.
Then it stops being funny.

Re: ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Fri, 07 Jan 2011 11:08:31
by gunderwood
For a second there I was thinking the world might be ending in 2012 after all...then I realized the ACLU hasn't changed at all.

I actually agree with their case (as much as I know about from the linked report and we know how accurate the "news" is). The founders argued that neither the Constitution, nor the government, give us our rights. They are natural rights and the law simply acknowledges them. If you are here legally I'm not sure how we could deny a lawful resident from keeping and bearing arms and remain consistent with the concept of natural rights.

Of course the linchpin is lawful residency. When you commit a crime, and being an illegal alien is a crime, the government has lawful ways to "violate" your rights, such as obtaining a warrant, etc. Doing that without due process is also another story.

Edit: Given the ACLUs track record I'm very concerned about their motives for pushing this. Somehow I think they are less than honorable.

Re: ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Fri, 07 Jan 2011 11:18:42
by TheGodfather
gunderwood wrote:Edit: Given the ACLUs track record I'm very concerned about their motives for pushing this. Somehow I think they are less than honorable.
Which is the very reason why I would fight them on this. Never deal with the devil. He's always got some trick up his sleave.

Re: ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Fri, 07 Jan 2011 11:47:08
by VBshooter
Agreed,, especially after all the other nonsese they have supported and wasted time with over the years..

Re: ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Fri, 07 Jan 2011 20:13:49
by DWinter
My guess is the criminals associated with the ACLU have a longer rap sheet than the entire membership of this board.

Re: ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Fri, 07 Jan 2011 21:47:27
by CowboyT
I'm finding myself agreeing with gunderwood on this one. This is a natural right, not one given to us by a government. Therefore, since Mr. Smith--the dude that the ACLU's backing--is a legal resident, the ACLU is correct in backing him.

Therefore, why should we, as pro-2A folks, oppose Mr. Smith's case? Can someome give me a Constitutional reason for doing so? If your case is good enough, then I will join you in opposing it.

Re: ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Sat, 08 Jan 2011 09:19:30
by LFS
CowboyT wrote:I'm finding myself agreeing with gunderwood on this one. This is a natural right, not one given to us by a government. Therefore, since Mr. Smith--the dude that the ACLU's backing--is a legal resident, the ACLU is correct in backing him.

Therefore, why should we, as pro-2A folks, oppose Mr. Smith's case? Can someome give me a Constitutional reason for doing so? If your case is good enough, then I will join you in opposing it.
I think you are right. My understanding is that he has been in this country legally for 30 years. Jumping to the conclusion that this is about illegal immigrants seems a bit xenophobic.

What is more interesting is that the Gun Owners of America, that no-compromise gun rights group that everybody swears the NRA should be more like, is against this guy having gun rights.

I do understand the hesitancy of supporting the ACLU. Their national organization has never been friendly to gun rights, though their supposed mission is to defend constitutional rights. However, some of the state-level chapters have funded gun rights cases in the past. After all, if Tom Gresham is an ACLU member they can't all be anti-gun.

Re: ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Sat, 08 Jan 2011 09:55:45
by VBshooter
From the story on FOX ;;;;;The lawsuit was filed this week on behalf of British national Wayne Smith, who legally immigrated 30 years ago, and for years was able to get a concealed license. In 2002, however, South Dakota amended the law, making U.S. citizenship a requirement to carry a concealed weapon. When Smith went to renew his long-held permit last July, he was denied because he is permanent LEGAL RESIDENT, not a citizen.


Technicality yes ;legal to deny him in SD? Yes! Now wether the ACLU is right on this or not ,South Dakota is within it's newly amended law to deny it based on the citizenship requirement, It would be fairer if they allowed grandfathering in ,but they don't so Wayne Smith is gonna have to fight a new law while the ACLU fiddle f&%$'s around trying to gain support instead of doing something tangible for him,.

Re: ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Sat, 08 Jan 2011 10:01:39
by gunderwood
LFS wrote:
CowboyT wrote:I'm finding myself agreeing with gunderwood on this one. This is a natural right, not one given to us by a government. Therefore, since Mr. Smith--the dude that the ACLU's backing--is a legal resident, the ACLU is correct in backing him.

Therefore, why should we, as pro-2A folks, oppose Mr. Smith's case? Can someome give me a Constitutional reason for doing so? If your case is good enough, then I will join you in opposing it.
I think you are right. My understanding is that he has been in this country legally for 30 years. Jumping to the conclusion that this is about illegal immigrants seems a bit xenophobic.
Are we even sure that it was the "gun rights" people who made that jump or is it just the media and our enemies making a false claim to bias the debate? Remember the "Constitution is the Bible" rants of the last week? I don't recall anyone saying or treating the Constitution as anything more than the supreme law of the land, but that didn't stop them from falsely painting the Tea Party activists as religious/political wakos.
LFS wrote:What is more interesting is that the Gun Owners of America, that no-compromise gun rights group that everybody swears the NRA should be more like, is against this guy having gun rights.
There is still a lot of information I don't know about the case yet. One of my biggest concerns is that they aren't trying to get this guy included in the state law, but rather to get the state laws about concealed carry thrown out completely or federalized. That is the last thing we want IMHO.
LFS wrote:I do understand the hesitancy of supporting the ACLU. Their national organization has never been friendly to gun rights, though their supposed mission is to defend constitutional rights. However, some of the state-level chapters have funded gun rights cases in the past. After all, if Tom Gresham is an ACLU member they can't all be anti-gun.
A lot of people, myself included, can't help but wonder what their actual goals are. I am highly suspicious of any claims that the ACLU has seen the light and their main objective is to get this guy included under the law as a lawful resident. I don't know what their twist on this is, but I suspect there is one...I hope I'm wrong though, but their track record is poor.

Re: ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Sat, 08 Jan 2011 11:00:16
by gunderwood
VBshooter wrote:From the story on FOX ;;;;;The lawsuit was filed this week on behalf of British national Wayne Smith, who legally immigrated 30 years ago, and for years was able to get a concealed license. In 2002, however, South Dakota amended the law, making U.S. citizenship a requirement to carry a concealed weapon. When Smith went to renew his long-held permit last July, he was denied because he is permanent LEGAL RESIDENT, not a citizen.


Technicality yes ;legal to deny him in SD? Yes! Now wether the ACLU is right on this or not ,South Dakota is within it's newly amended law to deny it based on the citizenship requirement, It would be fairer if they allowed grandfathering in ,but they don't so Wayne Smith is gonna have to fight a new law while the ACLU fiddle f&%$'s around trying to gain support instead of doing something tangible for him,.
Look at the big picture. Yes, he is a lawful resident and yes, the South Dakota law was amended to make him ineligible for a concealed carry permit. His case is arguing that SD doesn't have the authority to make that law. That makes it a State's rights question.

The 10th Amendment reserves everything else to the states and the people, so unless they can find something which would require SD to not have a citizenship requirement, SD has that authority. If SD has that authority, then it is a discussion about what SD's Constitution says because the people of SD may never have given the state government that power either. If all of that is true, the citizenship law is legal. However, just because it is legal doesn't make it right. Thus, even if it is legal, I think we should argue against such requirements to exercise natural rights.


Let's take a look at the 1st Amendment. It says Congress shall make no law. It is simple IMHO, Congress shall make no law regulating speech, the press, religion; nor can they set up a regulatory authority to do that either. Those regulatory authorities which do that are extra Constitutional and have no such authority, except that which Congress is willing to use their hired guns to enforce, but that is tyranny. However, does that mean the State's can't regulate those things? No, the 1st Amendment only says Congress shall make no law. The State's did make such regulatory laws concerning speech, the press and religion. You could argue against those laws, but it is a state question, not a federal question. The first question in this case is just that, but for the 2nd Amendment. This is the punctuation and capitalization which was distributed to the States and ratified by them:
A well regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the People to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.
This is a very different amendment than the First. It doesn't specify Congress or the Federal government at all. It gives a rational and then a ultimatum. Since this is the Federal governments Constitution there is no question it shall not infringe on the people's right to keep and bear arms (despite the fact it does and enforces it with the barrel of a gun despite having no such authority to do so). It is also clear that any State which ratified it, unlike the First, gave up its ability to infringe on the right to keep and bear arms. Remember the 10th Amendment reserves those power not given up or delegated, but this doesn't say the Federal government can't infringe like the First. It says the right shall not be infringed period. IMHO, any state which ratified it gave up its right to do so. Any further protection provided of this right provided to the people by the State's Constitutions is further recognition of their inability to regulate it. It is for this and ethical reasons that I fully support Constitutional carry for any lawful person.

Thus, IMHO there are only two remaining questions. Who are the "People" and what is infringement. IMO, infringement is anything which puts a burden on the "People" regarding the keeping and bearing of arms. Thus, the only gun laws we need are those which prohibit threatening to harm another person with a firearm; i.e. brandishing. Actually harming someone or their property is already covered and the weapon type should be irrelevant, so no additional laws are needed. Any law which prohibits or restricts the keeping and bearing of arms is infringement IMO. This doesn't mean violent criminals retain their gun rights though as that is part of the second question, who are the "People."

IMO, the People are any lawful resident of the States. The concept of U.S. citizenship didn't exist until the 14th Amendment:
Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
Until that point, people considered themselves and were legally citizens of the State in which they resided, not the United States. This amendment is the basis for the directly taxing and regulating the people at the Federal level. Thus, the Federal government subsided on taxing only those activities which crossed state borders. By making everyone a citizen of the federation, the People and the States gave up some of their power to the "federation." Not a good idea IMHO. At that point we were no longer a federation of anything, we were one State.

Getting back to the case, the question is does a lawful resident of the United State who isn't a citizen have 2nd Amendment rights? Unfortunately the 14th Amendment is poorly written IMHO. The first part probably doesn't apply to this guy, but the second does. SD can't deny him his due process, which they haven't. The law says X and they followed it. However, he is subject to the jurisdiction and must be given equal protection. The SD law doesn't seem to provide equal protection for all people under its jurisdiction.

Personally, I would love to see a split between the rights of citizens and the rights of all lawful people here. A citizen gets the right to vote, hold office and determine the future of government. All other lawful residents should be permitted to enjoy our freedoms while here. Illegal residents are a different story. They don't respect our laws and they should be deported. IMHO, dual citizenship should not be permitted either and you only become a citizen when at least one of your parents is a US citizen. Anyone who is a law abiding person (this includes our naturalization and work permit laws) should be able to come and participate in our society and enjoy the same freedoms. They should enjoy the same protection we do under the law, but they should have no say in our government, nor should Congress have amnesty powers.

Re: ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Sat, 08 Jan 2011 11:52:04
by zephyp
CowboyT wrote:I'm finding myself agreeing with gunderwood on this one. This is a natural right, not one given to us by a government. Therefore, since Mr. Smith--the dude that the ACLU's backing--is a legal resident, the ACLU is correct in backing him.

Therefore, why should we, as pro-2A folks, oppose Mr. Smith's case? Can someome give me a Constitutional reason for doing so? If your case is good enough, then I will join you in opposing it.
This is more a question about intent and I agree with the GOA position...this guy has been here for 30 years and he's not yet a citizen. Why not. if he wants to enjoy all of our rights and freedoms then he needs to join up and cut the apron strings across the pond...

Personally I have an issue with legal immigrants who stay here indefinitely without becoming a citizen. And, if there is a reason why he cannot become one then that raises even more questions...

This guy doesnt seem to fit the model of a lot I see though. Many legal (and illegal) immigrants come here clinging to their old way of life. They reside here but live as if they were still in their own country. If they want to do that why come here to begin with...

Re: ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Sat, 08 Jan 2011 11:56:16
by Yarddawg
zephyp wrote: This is more a question about intent and I agree with the GOA position...this guy has been here for 30 years and he's not yet a citizen. Why not. if he wants to enjoy all of our rights and freedoms then he needs to join up and cut the apron strings across the pond...

Personally I have an issue with legal immigrants who stay here indefinitely without becoming a citizen. And, if there is a reason why he cannot become one then that raises even more questions...

This guy doesnt seem to fit the model of a lot I see though. Many legal (and illegal) immigrants come here clinging to their old way of life. They reside here but live as if they were still in their own country. If they want to do that why come here to begin with...
+1 I have to agree with DK. Why not just go ahead and become a naturalized citizen at this point?

Re: ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Sat, 08 Jan 2011 12:38:44
by SgtBill
Yarddawg wrote:
zephyp wrote: This is more a question about intent and I agree with the GOA position...this guy has been here for 30 years and he's not yet a citizen. Why not. if he wants to enjoy all of our rights and freedoms then he needs to join up and cut the apron strings across the pond...

Personally I have an issue with legal immigrants who stay here indefinitely without becoming a citizen. And, if there is a reason why he cannot become one then that raises even more questions...

This guy doesnt seem to fit the model of a lot I see though. Many legal (and illegal) immigrants come here clinging to their old way of life. They reside here but live as if they were still in their own country. If they want to do that why come here to begin with...
+ 2 get the paperwork done and I am sure that it would be easy after being here for the past 30 year's.
Bill

+1 I have to agree with DK. Why not just go ahead and become a naturalized citizen at this point?

ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Sat, 08 Jan 2011 12:56:05
by gunderwood
I agree with zephyp, but think it is an immigration issue. There should be a limit for how long they can stay and not become a citizen. I don't think we should say they can not carry while they are lawfully here. However, just like illegal immigrants if they overstay the nonresident visa, they should be deported and charged with a crime so they can never reenter.

Re: ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Sat, 08 Jan 2011 18:22:40
by Mindflayer
It's the British cooking he doesn't want to give up.

Re: ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Sat, 08 Jan 2011 23:11:23
by Kreutz
Mindflayer wrote:It's the British cooking he doesn't want to give up.
Brain and kidney pie with a side of unrecognizable boiled vegetable mush and a nice piss warm Dirty Dick's Ale to wash it all down with is well worth this hassle.

Re: ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Sun, 09 Jan 2011 04:25:35
by CowboyT
zephyp wrote: This is more a question about intent and I agree with the GOA position...this guy has been here for 30 years and he's not yet a citizen. Why not. if he wants to enjoy all of our rights and freedoms then he needs to join up and cut the apron strings across the pond...

Personally I have an issue with legal immigrants who stay here indefinitely without becoming a citizen. And, if there is a reason why he cannot become one then that raises even more questions...

This guy doesnt seem to fit the model of a lot I see though. Many legal (and illegal) immigrants come here clinging to their old way of life. They reside here but live as if they were still in their own country. If they want to do that why come here to begin with...
Hmm...while I understand the sentiment, still, what's the Constitutional basis for denying this guy that natural right?

Re: ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Sun, 09 Jan 2011 06:10:32
by zephyp
CowboyT wrote:
zephyp wrote: This is more a question about intent and I agree with the GOA position...this guy has been here for 30 years and he's not yet a citizen. Why not. if he wants to enjoy all of our rights and freedoms then he needs to join up and cut the apron strings across the pond...

Personally I have an issue with legal immigrants who stay here indefinitely without becoming a citizen. And, if there is a reason why he cannot become one then that raises even more questions...

This guy doesnt seem to fit the model of a lot I see though. Many legal (and illegal) immigrants come here clinging to their old way of life. They reside here but live as if they were still in their own country. If they want to do that why come here to begin with...
Hmm...while I understand the sentiment, still, what's the Constitutional basis for denying this guy that natural right?
The Constitution of the United States - Preamble - We the People of the United States...
Although it doesnt come right out and say it the inference is that the Constitution was written for "we the people" - that is citizens of the US.

So, here's the quandary. If the Constitution is there for everyone regardless of citizenship status then what about illegals? Are they too afforded due process under the rights of the Constitution. Ok then, why cant they buy guns legally?

Following this little rabbit trail they should be able to and any law saying they cant can then be argued as un-Constitutional.

We cant open up one little portion of the Constitution. If legal immigrants (non-citizens) are afforded protection under the Constitution then why arent illegals as well. The Constitution does not specify that you have to be here lawfully to be afforded protection nor does it say otherwise. If I'm wrong then someone please correct me. Btw, not sayin I support this. I kinda think the Constitution is for citizens...you want to enjoy the benefits then again - sign up.

IMHO the only reason illegals cant buy guns is due to a law that can most likely be successfully argued as un-Constitutional if there is a lawyer dumb enough to try.

Re: ACLU wants to protect gun rights...

Posted: Sun, 09 Jan 2011 09:05:48
by Yarddawg
We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
I don't think that the Preamble of the Constitution could have been any clearer. It was written by Americans, for Americans. Therefore, if you seek the protections offered therein, you must be an American!